An interesting article entitled "The Renter's Manifesto: Why home ownership causes unemployment."

The article title is a bit misleading; it implies that home ownership causes unemployment. However, it explicitly states in the article: "English economist Andrew Oswald has shown that across European countries, and across U.S. states, high levels of home ownership are correlated with high levels of unemployment."

Semantics aside, this reminds me of the mentality shift I had a while ago regarding home ownership. I remember when I first started at MindTouch, I was saving a decent portion of my salary since I was living at home. Needing a goal to invest towards (it's really hard to save money when all these technology goodies stare at you from your RSS reader), I decided a "home" would be a good goal. I would save to buy a house.

A few months ago, I decided that buying a house would be a net-negative on my life. The article above gives a few reasons why (I drew similar conclusions), but the biggest reason why I had this shift away from house-buying was that house buying limits your career flexibility, and that is the best invesment of all - investing in yourself.

If the goal is future financial freedom as well as future happiness (my oversimplified definition of happiness: "being able to wake up/go to bed satisfied with your attempts at fulfilling your dreams"), then why should I willingly tie myself down to an area and set down roots? A house, if anything, clouds my decision making ability when it comes to a career, because I'll let the roots I've set down affect my career decision-making.

Realistically, if I had bought a house a few months ago in NC, could I have moved to San Diego? Would I be willing? If I had left MT, where would I have worked? IBM?

The most important advantage I have going in my life is my flexibility. My career mobility and my lack of roots will let me objectively determine if a specific job is the best thing for me.

I think it's a riskier path than taking a plush job at a big company, but it has a better potential upside. Risk, risk, risk.

Posted by roy on March 18, 2007 at 03:29 PM in Ramblings | 2 Comments

Related Entries

Want to comment with Tabulas?. Please login.

Comment posted on March 18th, 2007 at 06:45 PM
blah
btw.. i answered your other post first...

now for this one..

i would NEVER have bought in NC except for one singular rule.

Taxation on home sales capital gains is 0 if you buy another home to the area you move to.

yeah.. so since i bought a house, my cap gains is not taxed on my place in Cali... which is very significant considering i made a good amount offa my first place.
Comment posted on March 18th, 2007 at 03:56 PM
i agree 100%. it used to annoy the crap out of me when people would lecture me on how i'm throwing money away on rent. a house is not a good investment unless you are ready for it. simple as that.

now that i've decided to stay where i am for at least 5 or so more years, i'm ready to buy. but these decisions also differ amount people. i have friends who have no problem buying a house and then having to sell it even just after a few months for a career change. me, i couldn't handle all the stress of reselling, etc.